Guitar World Readers Poll: The Greatest Guitarist of All Time

[atomic charvel guy]

I know this list is missing alot of great players & probably has a few that shouldn't be there but..........................

No Victor Smolski or Kee Marcello?

those two guys are advanced great players, but can you actually get through
the song "Cherokee"? i cannot, if you can, my hat is off to you and enjoy it as that
is what music is for. "Music the driving force of nature" - i am quoting Vangelis, and that guy is a motherfucker
of a musician and composer.

[ulijdavid]

Kee Marcello didn't write "Cherokee" that was John Norum. As much as people puke on Europe, I think John Norum and Kee Marcello are great melodic guitarists.

But I am your typical short bus rider. I only visit this post after a trip to Walmart for sour cream and salsa pork rinds (engineers can't spell, so I don't know if I spelled pork rinds correct). I am here to view the intellectual elitism battle between Endrik and Metal Maniac. Metal Maniac much respect for graduating from MIT.

[atomic charvel guy]

Kee Marcello didn't write "Cherokee" that was John Norum. As much as people puke on Europe, I think John Norum and Kee Marcello are great melodic guitarists.

But I am your typical short bus rider. I only visit this post after a trip to Walmart for sour cream and salsa pork rinds (engineers can't spell, so I don't know if I spelled pork rinds correct). I am here to view the intellectual elitism battle between Endrik and Metal Maniac. Metal Maniac much respect for graduating from MIT.

UliJ,
Let me give you a little inside information on Endrik. He's a young kid, way beyond his years. Quite knowledgeable on many things,
he's not right about everything, but on most things i find he shoots pretty close to the dartboard, even when i don't agree with him.
Not to mention he came all the way out here from Estonia to visit me, unfortunately for him he was in culture shock
from the first minute. metal Maniac i do not know, and is just another one of us who has his favorites and his own taste,
and who's to say what's right or wrong? after myself of course, I am the all wise and ever knowing El Headacheo extraordinaireo.

[ulijdavid]

Cool, Estonia.......My Mom and Grandma came over on the "Boat" from Latvia. I went to school with a guy whose family was from Lithuania. The trilogy is complete. The Baltic states are all accounted for.

Seriously, I don't know either Metal Maniac or Endrik. The post just became an intellectual tennis match. No disrespect to either, just adding my crap.

[horns666]

Hey you dicks.

Somebody tell this fag to listen to "Machine Gun"...http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...Vyk_TObCo&NR=1

[atomic charvel guy]

bill,
That was the ugliest piece of music i may have ever heard, thanks alot, and fuck you.

[METAL MANIAC]

UliJ,
Let me give you a little inside information on Endrik. He's a young kid, way beyond his years. Quite knowledgeable on many things,
he's not right about everything, but on most things i find he shoots pretty close to the dartboard, even when i don't agree with him.
Not to mention he came all the way out here from Estonia to visit me, unfortunately for him he was in culture shock
from the first minute. metal Maniac i do not know, and is just another one of us who has his favorites and his own taste,
and who's to say what's right or wrong? after myself of course, I am the all wise and ever knowing El Headacheo extraordinaireo.

Did not know he was a young Kid.......very impressive.......very intellegent......I will drop the back and forth but at the same time no need to blame me for the whole thing....yeah you don't know me but that does not mean my opinion is any less valuable than his or anyboby else for that matter........I do not think I am better than anyone else but I refuse to be anyone's door mat!

[atomic charvel guy]

exactly where did I blame you? I said you were another one of us with your own taste. gadzooks. and when i say young kid, that means anyone
under 30. i an ancient.
here's the bottom line on Yngwie according to "my taste"- as a guitar player i have him very high up on the ability level, probably the highest.
but as a songwriter, he's one dimensional at the very best, and i find that odd given his love of Blackmore and Hendrix.
and in the end, if i can't listen to a song, it gets the proverbial "yngwie Axe" real quick.

[atomic charvel guy]

Metal Maniac,
I don't blame you for anything, in fact, i'm glad you've livened the place up.
I'm an old buzzard and speak often with sarcasm, my mouth is so big it's unmeasurable.
You'll find me as easy to get along with as anyone, unfortunately, postings can be easily
misunderstood as you cannot hear the inflection of the person writing them. don't go away is what i am saying, haa haa!!

[atomic charvel guy]

Spoono Gettin'Snort (Nuno Bettencourt) is so remarkable, not just his leads,m, but his song structure
is fantastic as well, but I can't get past Gary Cherone for very long, and not because he can't sing,
he can belt them out, but his voice just headaches my ears in large doses.
the first Extreme album is a mixed tone of very early EVH and Warren DeMartini "Invasion of Your Privacy" neighborhood type sound, and it's fuckin' ridiculously
great. Pat Badger is a strong bass player too, they can all sing as well, but something about Gary's voice just
doesn't do it for me, imagine Nuno paired up with a Ray Gillen, or Sebastian Bach, etc. that would be interesting.

[Endrik]

Blame Tommy for my recent message board ejaculations. That fucking fruitbat. But since he called me back here I see no reason why I can't exercise some english here, had fairly little practice in that language this year... so why not with snobby manner? I've done plenty of replies à la "suck a dick bitch!" or something similar in that style. I'm no authority in English language, but I'm an authority when it comes to pork, so someone even mentioning walmart pork rinds makes me to go out and get some Jamón Ibérico de Bellota... damn, being an elitists is much more fun and tastier experience than being a bolshevik.

Tommy and Bill get me and so do some of the others who are closer friends here as they understand my sarcastic manner and dry sense of humour... that's the way a lot of my friends communicate. I know I annoy the shit out of many but at least those who get me, get some kick out of it.
I remember the time when a lot of heated debates and bullshit was going on, It was pretty fun, certainly boosted up people's writing skills and some critical thinking (for those who didn't pussed out), Bengal was the man in this.

[Snoogans]

I'm no authority in English language

Bullshit! You use English better than most English folks I meet here in England!

[METAL MANIAC]

exactly where did I blame you? I said you were another one of us with your own taste. gadzooks. and when i say young kid, that means anyone
under 30. i an ancient.
here's the bottom line on Yngwie according to "my taste"- as a guitar player i have him very high up on the ability level, probably the highest.
but as a songwriter, he's one dimensional at the very best, and i find that odd given his love of Blackmore and Hendrix.
and in the end, if i can't listen to a song, it gets the proverbial "yngwie Axe" real quick.

I agree his song writing skills are lacking....his talent is what draws him to me............

[METAL MANIAC]

Metal Maniac,
I don't blame you for anything, in fact, i'm glad you've livened the place up.
I'm an old buzzard and speak often with sarcasm, my mouth is so big it's unmeasurable.
You'll find me as easy to get along with as anyone, unfortunately, postings can be easily
misunderstood as you cannot hear the inflection of the person writing them. don't go away is what i am saying, haa haa!!

Oh, I was not planning to....I was watching Metallic Live 84.......That is what made me think of this thread.............MM

[METAL MANIAC]

" people's writing skills and some critical thinking."

Thanks for the help with that. I am currently working toward another degree, mostly involving writing.....so being on the defensive is helping.................MM