If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
And NextInLine "since guitar solos aren't important that much anymore: " er, you're posting that on a Jackson forum? Don't most people here think guitar solos are VERY important? I know I do!
To me it is, but judging by the last album & TSHF it's not to the majority anymore.. And I could live without solos instead of having shitty ones.
Jeff Waters commented on the whole thing though, which makes me think he KNOWS something's happened with Drover.
And NextInLine "since guitar solos aren't important that much anymore: " er, you're posting that on a Jackson forum? Don't most people here think guitar solos are VERY important? I know I do!
Sinistas was right too - Polands leads on TSHF sucked badly.
"Although MEGADETH has yet to confirm Glen's departure via its official web site, numerous postings on various message boards (including MEGADETH's official forum, where such messages are regularly deleted) have suggested that Drover has left the band in order to focus on family life."
Though apparently there are some issues with Glen, nothing official has come from the Megadeth camp or has been posted on Broderick's site, and all the gossip has originated on internet message boards.
...And we all know how accurate internet message boards are. You guys are like a bunch of old ladies...
Not only that, didn't Blabbermouth has a story claiming Ace Frehley had died recently?
Last edited by khabibissell; 01-12-2008, 04:08 PM.
I think J-Lo's fucking great! I wouldn't want him to go to det Ellefson back. And even I sing better than Jr.
If Dave could get Marty back, and some anonymous drummer, the band would be perfect. Menza's playing's what I call "ideal" for metal songs. It's very creative and it's not just brrrrrrrrrrr double bass drum. But I don't think Dave would get him back anytime. They seem to be not getting along well.And since I'm not that proficient on understanding the drum tracks,any decent drummer would do for me, I guess.
I have to agree with Sinistas, whatever Dave does it disappoints or pisses off someone. I can't see any right choice for Dave in this situation.
The only & best thing he could do to make people happy was keep going with the same line-up which was about to happen this time but seems to be dead in the water already.
In fact all these arguments about Megadeth's line up is a bit pointless. Since Dave's writing most of the stuff, and since guitar solos aren't important that much anymore. As for live performance, as long as the band is playing tight it's not that important to have a guitar player who can nail the solos because Megadeth has had a bigger problem than that, which is Dave's singing. I've watched many 'Deth concerts and I've seen only a couple shows in which Dave's singing is decent And Dave can easily form a line up which could play the songs real tight So live performance isn't really an issue..
And my point is that there are not many musicians out there now who can write a "Sleepwalker" or "Washington's Next" Whatever line up he's with or whatever name he gives to "HIS" band, as long as he can write a couple more classics, I'm in and I appreciate him. No need to argue his choices and if the lead player can nail Marty solos or not, that doesn't matter, but if Marty was back it would be killer.
I think it's pretty cool that Mustaine has a Megadeth cover band.
Dave started the band, created the concept, and wrote at least 85% of the catalogue himself. Did anybody really believe that Ellefson would escape the revolving door? Yes, it was cool to have that link to the glory days or whatever, but I think it's better than say, Jerry Only's version of the Misfits.
Who'd you like to be back in the band? Let's go over the options:
- Ellefson: Hasn't done anything interesting bass-wise in 20 years. Horrendous backing vocals. Decent stage presence.
- Friedman: Would be the best option of any prior member, IMO...But, does he WANT to give up his mainstream exposure and popularity in Japan? I strongly doubt it.
- Menza: Fuck Menza...Anybody connected with Orphaned To Hatred deserves to rot. The "Life After Deth" cd blew ass, also.
- Poland: Go listen to TSHF and tell me if that's the person you want writing leads...Not me.
- Pitrelli / Degrasso: By all accounts, the TWNAH lineup was the most miserable to deal with.
- Young / Behler: Yeah, no.
So, you tell me...What would you do? The best chance out of all these guys is Ellefson, and I think, apart from nostalgia, that Lomenzo's a much better choice.
Leave a comment: