Metallica or Megadeth?

[Spivonious]

Wow - I have a completely different opinion of CTE. To me, CTE is Metallica's Black Album, or rather, Megadeth's attempt at it.

Wow, I think CTE is #3 best 'deth album. #1 RIP, #2 PSBWB, #3 CTE.

Architecture of Aggression, Ashes in Your Mouth, Psychotron, they all destroy anything on the black album.

I think Megadeth has kept growing, which is good. Metallica ran out of ideas 15 years ago.

[VitaminG]

hasn't metallica gone on record before about making a conscious decision to do something different also? bith bands did. metallica just chose a more commercial direction. megadeth went different but still stayed JUST below the mainstream radar....

Metallica got haircuts & cowboy hats.

[markD]

true, but they are going kinda bald too. i wear a cowboy hat onstage to hide my giant growing bald area. i don't wanna shave my head totally yet because skull is shaped funny.

maybe metallica felt the same way. though kirk looks cooler with short hair....kinda like bruce dickinson.

[MartinBarre]

Anthrax.

[MartinBarre]

kirk looks cooler with short hair....kinda like bruce dickinson.

A Mexican Bruce Dickinson? :idea:

[Rupe]

Anthrax.

[Tekky]

Metallica got haircuts & cowboy hats.

Rumor is that they wear ass-less chaps backstage.

[markD]

A Mexican Bruce Dickinson? :idea:

grito por me largo playa!!!!!!

(i don't speak spansih at all, so excuse my joke)

[horns666]

Rumor is that they wear ass-less chaps backstage.

Sweet..

BTW..I'm goin' with Testament!

Then Exodus!

Fuggums.

[horns666]

Sweet..

BTW..I'm goin' with Testament!

Then Exodus!

Fuggums.

Ahhh ..Nevermore slays them all!!!

[khabibissell]

I'll have to go with Metallica on this one because I think they are better songwriters. James is a great rhythm guitar player, and though Kirk isn't the most technically perfect player in the world and has slipped in the last decade, he was very influential to me growing up. I thought his playing on AJFA and MOP was the tops. Hell I wore out two cassettes of AJFA I listened to it so much. I liked the Black Album too. Good production and catchy songs. Productions aside, I think Death Magnetic is an excellent effort and like just about every song on it. Never got into Load/Reload.

I don't like much of Megadeth's catalog really, with the exception being RIP and Countdown. I am a huge fan of those two records. The lineup Dave had (Marty, Nick, and Junior) was his best IMO. Marty's solos are always incredibly unique and inspiring. Actually, the main thing I like about 'Deth is Marty's playing. The songwriting was pretty good during that era as well.

[horns666]

Metallica sucked the pole from 1991 to well now. "Death Magnetic" isn't the redeemer everyone says it is. "Deth fucked up with Risk and learned from that quick and without tongue kissing any of his metro-sexual bandmates.

Megadeth stayed metal. Metalilca did not! That's kinda inportant to a metalhead...ya think?

I'm mean if you like suggin' the cock, that's cool..suck the fuck out of it. I just don't wanna see it, because I'm homophobic..or my cock is..because it inverts like a scared turtle at just a glimpse of male gayness. But I love and support all lesbianisms!

Don't get me wrong, I cringe at any display of public affection..it's what 15 year old do. Who wants to watch two assholes going at it in resturant while you're trying to eat. Not me..I ALWAYS call 'em on it!! Get a fuggin' room ya bastids!

[BeholdTheFallen]

after seeing the Metallica Guitar Hero Commercial, I may be forced to change to MegaDeth..

naw I'm gonna go with slayer.

[Jacksons Shred]

If Slayer and Anthrax are in this equation.. Fuck it, I choose Pantera up till FBD.

[horns666]

Well here's the bottom line IMO!!!

Megadeth live with their new song in 2007..http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i0_ls9fOavg

Metallica live with their new song in 2007..http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sW1Na...eature=related

I stayed true to the band that stayed most true to me ..

Obviously I'm not the only METALHEAD that feels this way.

With Chris Broderick in the Megacamp..it will only get better.