Re: Anthrax and Jackson
Personally, across the board, if I like a band's sound and style, I prefer for them to stay the same. However, if they feel the need for change, I'm not above giving the new stuff a chance. The difference isn't WHETHER it changes, it's whether I LIKE how it's changed.
I'm a huge old-Anthrax fan, play lots of their songs. I loved Joey's voice, I loved their early sound, and I loved the songs and subjects. I've idolized the old Anthrax guitars for years, and I'd have done anything to get an RR like Danny's with the TMNT graphics, or a copy of Scott's Judge Dredd ESP. Along with Metallica in their early years, these were the guys who made me wanna play guitar.
Persistence of Time was a big change in both tone of their guitars and tone of their attitude in the lyrics. But I loved it.
Then, Joey was gone and Bush came in. I was skeptical, because I've never heard much Armored Saint, and really didn't want to see Joey go. But, regardless of the why's, once I got Sound of White Noise, though it was extremely different than anything previous, I loved it, too.
Then came Stomp and Volume 8. UG! The guitar sound became a wash of mostly undefined mud, and the songs...UG!...couldn't stand the music, composition, or lyrics in the slightest. I had pretty much given up on Anthrax for good (as I had Metallica after Load *puke*).
But, I don't know how they did it, but they managed to somehow...get better to me, with WCFYA. Not loved...just...well...I like it better than Stomp and V8. Some of the songs are really catchy and cool...some I think are are just dopey and stupid, but at least I can listen to the album without completely wanting to shut it off hehehe.
The difference, though: After Sound of White Noise, there's nothing on these albums I have even a slight interest in playing on guitar. It's guitar composition designed around "the song" much more than around "kickass riffs", and just doesn't interest me at all. I'd emailed in before WCFYA and complained there was nothing on the previous albums I had wanted to learn, there were no defined, cool riffs, and "Scott Ian" (or whomever replies to their emails with his name) replied that WCFYA would be "riffier". Ehhh...well...it's better...but there's still nothing on there I'd care to want to play hehehe.
Stu
Personally, across the board, if I like a band's sound and style, I prefer for them to stay the same. However, if they feel the need for change, I'm not above giving the new stuff a chance. The difference isn't WHETHER it changes, it's whether I LIKE how it's changed.
I'm a huge old-Anthrax fan, play lots of their songs. I loved Joey's voice, I loved their early sound, and I loved the songs and subjects. I've idolized the old Anthrax guitars for years, and I'd have done anything to get an RR like Danny's with the TMNT graphics, or a copy of Scott's Judge Dredd ESP. Along with Metallica in their early years, these were the guys who made me wanna play guitar.
Persistence of Time was a big change in both tone of their guitars and tone of their attitude in the lyrics. But I loved it.
Then, Joey was gone and Bush came in. I was skeptical, because I've never heard much Armored Saint, and really didn't want to see Joey go. But, regardless of the why's, once I got Sound of White Noise, though it was extremely different than anything previous, I loved it, too.
Then came Stomp and Volume 8. UG! The guitar sound became a wash of mostly undefined mud, and the songs...UG!...couldn't stand the music, composition, or lyrics in the slightest. I had pretty much given up on Anthrax for good (as I had Metallica after Load *puke*).
But, I don't know how they did it, but they managed to somehow...get better to me, with WCFYA. Not loved...just...well...I like it better than Stomp and V8. Some of the songs are really catchy and cool...some I think are are just dopey and stupid, but at least I can listen to the album without completely wanting to shut it off hehehe.
The difference, though: After Sound of White Noise, there's nothing on these albums I have even a slight interest in playing on guitar. It's guitar composition designed around "the song" much more than around "kickass riffs", and just doesn't interest me at all. I'd emailed in before WCFYA and complained there was nothing on the previous albums I had wanted to learn, there were no defined, cool riffs, and "Scott Ian" (or whomever replies to their emails with his name) replied that WCFYA would be "riffier". Ehhh...well...it's better...but there's still nothing on there I'd care to want to play hehehe.
Stu
Comment