Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

[atomic charvel guy]

the best hitter i have ever seen play is rod carew, but this list includes the whole show. who are your top ten?
mine are-(not including babe ruth)
1-shoeless Joe Jackson
2-Ted Williams
3-Ty Cobb
4-Joe DiMaggio
5-Lou Gehrig
6-Rod Carew
7-Tony Gwynn
8-Wade Boggs
9-Honus Wagner
10-Don Mattingly

(p.s.-i hate pete rose and barry bonds so this is a half true , half prejudiced list)

[sully]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

tommy, i'm surprised that you don't have bucky dent in there, just to give me shit. [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img] i'm not the baseball historian that you are, but here's who pops into my mind, in no order:

- harold baines
- frank thomas
- ron kittle (okay, maybe just 1983)
- ted williams
- david ortiz
- johnny damon
- manny ramirez
- babe ruth (duh)
- roger maris
- raphael palmeiro (sp?)

[Soloist1]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

Mattingly? That's a joke right? lol I agree with your top 5 being in there though. From Sully's list I'd add his bottom 4. Papi needs a couple more years to make that list. But I'm sure he'll be there. Manny and Papi are on pace to once again pass Gehrig and Ruth for back to back hitters with over 130 rbi's and 30 hr's.

[Razor]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

I'm suprised Reggie Jackson didn't make either list.

[Drsracing]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

1. Ted williams
2. Geroge Brett
3. Ty cobb
4. Ken Griffey Jr.
5. Ichiro
6. Pete Rose
7. Tony Gwyen
8. Hank AAron
9. Willie Mays
10.Dale Murphy

[atomic charvel guy]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

he dares to mock donnie baseball, oh the sacrilege. if he did not hurt his back he would have went down with some sick numbers. 200 hits a year, he battled boggs alot for the batting title. it's my list and i can put who ever i want on it-lol
i left out 25 other guys, willie mays, jimmie fox, hank greenberg, etc. etc. etc .

[mudkicker]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

1. The Babe. He set the benchmark. Can you imagine how many homers he could have hit sober and on steroids?
2. Johnny Bench ( Huge fan. I wore number 5 from peewee to highschool ball.)
3. Pudge
4. Pete rose
5. Mike Schmidt (SP)
6. Rod Carew
7. Tony Gwynn
8. Chipper Jones
9. Big Mac
10. Jose Conseco (Before he became a head case. Bash brotha days in Oakland with Big Mac).

[Ralph E.]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

Like him or not, where the hell is Barry Bonds?

[Soloist1]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

On enhancement alley same as McGuire and Sosa. Sorry Tommy. I'm a huge Nomar fan and would make an arguement for him because of it. But he's not in the same league and neither is Mattingly.

[BLOOD SPLATTER]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

Best hitter ever....Cam F*cking Neely!!

[Crusher]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

My personal favorite Baseball hitters/batters:

1. Babe Ruth
2. Ted Williams
3. Ty Cobb
4. Mickey Mantle
5. Wade Boggs
6. Keith Hernandez
7. Gary Carter
8. Rickey Henderson
9. Carlton Fisk
10. Carl Yztremski

[donf]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

1. Babe Ruth
2. Joe Dimaggio
3. Lou Gehrig
4. Yogi Berra
5. Mickey Mantle
6. Don Mattingly
7. Reggie Jackson
8. Oscar Gamble
9. Bucky Dent
10 Aaron Boone

Whatja expect? 26 World Series titles! [img]/images/graemlins/toast.gif[/img]

[mwm70]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

Peter North
Jack Hammer
Ron Jeremy

[Superfly]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

NO WAY i can put them in 1-10 escept for Ted. Game Over...

- Ted Williams
- Manny Ramirez
- David Ortiz
- Joe Dimaggio
- Ken Griffey Jr
- Tony Gwynn
- Rickey Henderson
- Lou Gehrig
- Willie Mays
- George Brett

[Hellraiser6502]

Re: Your Top 10 Hitters of All Time

In no particular order

-Sammy Sosa
-Jose Canseco
-Reggie Jackson
-Hank Aaron
-Barry Bonds
-Manny Ramirez
-Ken Griffey Jr.
-Mark McGwire
-Tony Gwynn
-Pete Rose