OMG.........that sukked!!!!

[donf]

Now, I normally like remakes of songs, just because it gives it a different taste, but coming home from work, I listened to a song that sukked soooooooooooo bad.

It was 'Turn the Page' by Metallica. Do you think they could've possibily stacked any more (shit) effects, distortion and bad vocals on top of a normally quiet song.

This is equivalent to taking a song like 'Dust In the Wind' by Kansas, playing it in Drop D tuning, thru an octave pedal, delay pedal, flanger, metal zone pedal, wah wah pedal, run it thru a Leslie cabinet. Throw a little distorted accordian for just a 'little' more effect.

Hetfield sounds like a cross between Yoko Ono and Phil Anselamo on that song.

Sorry. That was horrible

[6_string_master]

I know, its a horrible song. Kinda sad how Metallica has gone a totally different direction. To me they havent matured in their music.

[rjohnstone]

+1,000,000
I hated that version of the song.
Bob should have nut kicked James for singing so badly.

[donf]

+1,000,000
I hated that version of the song.
Bob should have nut kicked James for singing so badly.

It might of helped the vocals.:ROTF: :ROTF:

[donf]

The only remake I could think that would be worse is Jewel's rendition of Crazy Train. :ROTF:

[zeegler]

Shinedown did Simple Man, and it was horrendous. Really fucking horrible.

[OnlineStageGear]

That is actually about the only decent thing they have done since the black album, and they didn't write it.

[Newc]

Agreed. I heard the Bob Seeger version and thought it was a bit too weak and had no emotional impact, and Metallica's version had what was missing.

I guess it depends on which one you hear first.

[wulfe13]

I thought Metallicas version was ok. I have a friend that doesn't even like Old Metallica and he LOVES their version of Turn the Page....

Zeeg, Simple Man has always been my favorite Skynard song and I think Shinedown did an AMAZING job on it. I like it better than the original!

[hippietim]

Agreed. I heard the Bob Seeger version and thought it was a bit too weak and had no emotional impact, and Metallica's version had what was missing.

I guess it depends on which one you hear first.

Newclehead.

[Bandersnatch]

The only remake I could think that would be worse is Jewel's rendition of Crazy Train. :ROTF:

What about Lil John's crazy train cover??

[Reverend Timmy]

I saw Shinedown about 3 weeks ago and they knocked Simple Man out of the park.Much better than the album version.They were actually pretty good.....

[mm2002]

I liked Metallicas version of TTP better than Segers' myself. Just a matter of preference I suppose.

[El_Kabong]

I'm waitng for their cover of 'Lay Down Sally'.

[donf]

I guess its personal preference. I just thought that song was aborted so bad, no one would like it.

Come to think of it. I'd rather listen to that song, than any song by U2.:ROTF: :ROTF: :ROTF: