Satch sues Coldplay

[Bert]

Ah yes, here it is:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUhFLiw6h6s

[Bert]

Wasn't there some other no-name band suing coldplay for plagiarism over this exact same song about a year back?!

[levantin]

We now know that Joe is listening to Coldplay.

More likely that the record company lawyers are. Sometimes the artist has nothing to do with stuff like this. But anyhow why not listen to Coldplay. Not my cup of tea but I see the appeal in their music (yes I'm a pussy).

[levantin]

i could see satriani's side BUT the chances of a shitty band like coldplay having even the remotest clue who he is, ...

If you play guitar, you've heard of Satch, or you live under a rock. You may or may not like what you've heard, but you've heard it. What you're suggesting is being a driver and not having heard of Schumacher.

[SouthPlatteDemon]

We now know that Joe is listening to Coldplay.

[rjohnstone]

maybe they are doing it because Joe stoled from Los Enanitos Verdes? :ROTF:

Probably.

Ain't the music biz a trip?

[Endrik]

You have it backwards. It's not about encroachment.
It's about Coldplay profiting off of Joe's work.

maybe they are doing it because Joe stoled from Los Enanitos Verdes? :ROTF:

[hippietim]

Coldplay have stolen from the Great One. The sentence is death.

WTF? Coldplay has stolen from Steve Vai?

[Rsmacker]

Coldplay have stolen from the Great One. The sentence is death.

[åron]

Was it Vivaldi who said, "Good artists borrow, great artists steal"? I think it was. Satch is a whore? We already knew that. With all this music, all these musicians and now in this age where anyone can publish, the courts could eventually reverse themselves on this sort of thing. Maybe this case goes to trial, but I'd wager Coldplay would win. There's no way any of those guys listen to Satch and there's got to be at least a couple public domain works with that melody over those changes. Gay wasn't invented in 2004!

[rjohnstone]

i'm just saying i don't see how it encroaches upon any profit he makes in his niche market....so why the bother? he just sounds liek he wants an excuse for the money, which is sad

You have it backwards. It's not about encroachment.
It's about Coldplay profiting off of Joe's work.

And I don't think Joe has any money issues.
Ever been to one of his concerts? I've been to many and they were always sold out.

Tim... I agree.. I think both songs suck too.
But that's not the point here.

[Dreamland_Rebel]

hell, this has been going on since the beginning of music.

Led Zepplin stole the theme for "stairway to heaven" from part of Spirit's song "Taurus".

Beck's "Loser" is Allman Brothers "Midnight Rider" tuned down.

At the Gates should just sue every metalcore band. hehheh.

[sonicsamurai]

Your opinion, but I digress.

Again, this is relevant how?
Plagiarism is plagiarism. Ones stature in an industry, real or perceived, is irrelevant.

In your opinion, the niche writer has no claim simply because he lacks some perceived level of popularity?

i'm just saying i don't see how it encroaches upon any profit he makes in his niche market....so why the bother? he just sounds liek he wants an excuse for the money, which is sad

[hippietim]

I must be the only one that thinks both songs suck.

[rjohnstone]

its relevant because it helps to illustrate the fact that coldplay are a much bigger and (unfortunately) much more widely respected and acclaimed within the music industry of the populist masses

Your opinion, but I digress.

Again, this is relevant how?
Plagiarism is plagiarism. Ones stature in an industry, real or perceived, is irrelevant.

In your opinion, the niche writer has no claim simply because he lacks some perceived level of popularity?